Finding the best saddlebags for Harley Softail can be a challenge, as options vary widely in style, capacity, and price. The Unknown Product stands out for its classic design and reliable durability, making it a solid overall choice. The XMT-MOTO Hard Saddlebags are excellent for riders who prioritize security with lockable lids, while the KEMIMOTO Large Capacity Saddlebags offer ample space for longer trips. Riders often face tradeoffs between size, ease of installation, and weather resistance. Continue reading for a detailed breakdown of these options and more to find your perfect fit.
Key Takeaways
- The top saddlebags balance capacity, weatherproofing, and ease of installation without excessive bulk.
- Lockable lids and secure mounting are key features for riders concerned about theft and stability.
- Materials like PU leather combined with waterproofing significantly extend the lifespan of saddlebags.
- Larger capacity bags tend to add weight and may impact handling, so consider your riding style.
- Budget-friendly options often sacrifice some features like weather resistance or locking mechanisms.
More Details on Our Top Picks
XMT-MOTO Hard Saddlebags with Lids and Keys for Harley Davidson 1994-2013 Touring & 1984-2017 Softail (Gloss Black)
The XMT-MOTO Hard Saddlebags excel in offering rugged durability with their ABS construction, making them a strong choice for riders who prefer sturdy, lockable storage. Compared to the 5″ Vivid Black Painted Saddlebags, which focus on style and extended looks, these hard bags prioritize security and weather resistance, making them suitable for longer trips. Their included keys and latches provide added security, but the need for optional conversion brackets means some riders may face additional costs or modifications. While the ABS material is tough, it may feel less premium than metal options, and some models might require minor adjustments for perfect fit. Overall, this pick makes the most sense for those who prioritize durability and security over sleek styling.
Pros:- Heavy-duty ABS construction resists impacts and weather
- Includes keys and latches for secure closure
- Fits multiple Harley Davidson models with optional brackets
Cons:- Conversion brackets are not included, potentially increasing setup time and cost
- Some models may need modifications for perfect fit
Best for: Touring riders seeking tough, lockable storage that fits a wide range of Harley Softail and Touring models.
Not ideal for: Riders looking for lightweight, stylish, or fully integrated aesthetic solutions that don’t require modifications.
- Material:ABS
- Fits:Harley Davidson 1994-2013 Touring, 1984-2017 Softail
- Color:Gloss Black
- Includes:Left and right saddlebags, 2 keys, 2 latches
Bottom line: This model suits riders who prioritize ruggedness and security over sleek aesthetics and are willing to handle minor installation adjustments.
5″ Vivid Black Painted Extended Stretched Saddlebags for Harley Touring Models 2014-2024
The 5″ Vivid Black Painted Saddlebags stand out for their extended, stretched profile that significantly enhances the visual profile of Harley Touring models from 2014 to 2024. Made from durable ABS plastic, they are pre-drilled for straightforward installation, making them appealing for riders seeking a custom look without extensive modifications. Compared to hard-shell options like XMT-MOTO, these focus more on aesthetic appeal, but they may lack some of the security features and weather resistance of more rugged designs. The plastic construction keeps weight down but might be less durable over long-term use or in harsh weather conditions. Overall, this choice makes sense for riders prioritizing a bold, stretched aesthetic and easy installation over maximum durability or security.
Pros:- Durable, vivid black finish resists scratches and weather
- Pre-drilled for simple, quick installation
- Extended, stretched design boosts visual impact
Cons:- Limited to 2014-2024 models; not compatible with newer or special edition bikes
- Plastic construction may be less resistant to impacts over time
Best for: Style-conscious riders wanting a stretched, custom look that’s easy to install on touring models.
Not ideal for: Riders planning heavy touring or off-road use where durability and security are paramount.
- Material:ABS Plastic
- Color:Vivid Black
- Fitment:Harley 2014-2024 Touring Models
- Package Included:Left & Right Saddlebags
Bottom line: This pick is ideal for riders seeking a bold, stretched style with straightforward installation, but it’s less suited for demanding long-term use or off-road conditions.
KEMIMOTO Motorcycle Saddle Bags with Cup Holder 18L Waterproof PU Leather
This pair of saddle bags stands out for their practicality and style, especially with a generous 18L capacity that comfortably accommodates essential gear. Compared to the larger 30L options like the KEMIMOTO 30L Large Capacity PU Leather Luggage Bag, these are more suited for riders who value a balance between storage and sleekness, but they do impose limits on long-distance packing. The waterproof PU leather construction, reinforced structure, and quick-release buckles make them convenient and durable for typical cruiser rides. However, their limited compatibility—requiring at least 3 inches clearance from the tailpipe—means they aren’t the best choice for all Softail models, especially those with tight spacing or heavy rain. The external water bottle pockets add utility, yet the bags’ durability might wane in persistent heavy rain. Overall, this pick makes the most sense for riders seeking a stylish, easy-to-install saddlebag with moderate capacity for weekend trips.
Pros:- Large 18L capacity suitable for essentials
- Water-resistant PU leather construction
- Quick-release buckles for easy access
- Stylish red accent stitching
Cons:- Requires at least 3 inches clearance from tailpipe, limiting compatibility
- May be less durable in heavy rain or prolonged exposure
Best for: Harley Softail riders who want a durable, stylish saddlebag suitable for short to mid-range rides.
Not ideal for: Long-distance touring riders who need maximum storage capacity and weather resistance for extended trips.
- Capacity:18L
- Material:PU Leather
- Waterproof:Yes
- Mounting Compatibility:Softail, Dyna, Road King, V-Star, Shadow, Vulcan, Universal
- Dimensions:9L x 2 (per bag)
Bottom line: This saddlebag offers a balanced combination of style, convenience, and moderate capacity, ideal for everyday cruising and short trips.
KEMIMOTO Motorcycle Saddlebags, 30L Large Capacity PU Leather Luggage Bag for Motorcycles
This 30L set of saddlebags offers significantly more storage than the 18L option, making them suitable for riders who need to carry more gear or longer trips. Compared with the KEMIMOTO 18L Saddle Bags, their larger size makes them less sleek but more practical for daily commuting or weekend adventures. Made from water-resistant PU leather and featuring easy-to-install adjustable straps, these bags are compatible with a wide range of models including Softail and Dyna. Still, they require proper clearance from the exhaust and may not fit all models perfectly, especially those with tight spacing. While their size is a major advantage, their bulk could interfere with maneuverability in tight spaces. If you need maximum capacity, these are a dependable choice, but for riders focused on a cleaner aesthetic or minimalism, lighter options might be better.
Pros:- Large 30L capacity for extensive storage
- Water-resistant PU leather construction
- Universal fit with easy installation
- Adjustable straps for secure mounting
Cons:- Not compatible with some specific models like Sportster 48 Iron 883
- Requires at least 3 inches clearance from exhaust
- Could be too bulky for tight bike spaces
Best for: Harley Softail riders who prioritize maximum storage capacity for commuting or short trips.
Not ideal for: Riders with bikes that have limited clearance or who prefer a minimal look, as these bags are bulkier and require careful fitting.
- Capacity:30L
- Dimensions:13.8 x 6.3 x 10.8 inches
- Material:PU Leather
- Color:Black
Bottom line: This set is ideal for riders needing maximum storage, especially for short trips or errands, despite some size limitations.
KEMIMOTO Motorcycle Saddlebags, 30L Large Capacity PU Leather Side Bags with Anti-Scalding Bottom, Compatible with Sportster, Softail, Dyna, V-Star, Shadow
This 30L set emphasizes safety and durability with a high-temperature resistant bottom, making it a smart choice for riders worried about heat exposure near exhaust pipes. Compared to the KEMIMOTO 18L Saddle Bags, these offer more capacity and added safety features, but they are bulkier and require precise fitting, as they are incompatible with some models like Sportster 48 Iron 883. Their waterproof PU leather ensures protection against the elements, but they still need a minimum clearance of 3 inches from the tailpipe. The anti-scalding bottom enhances safety, especially for long rides with hot exhausts. While their large capacity is a plus, riders with smaller or tightly spaced bikes might find them too cumbersome. This set is best for riders who need large, weatherproof storage and extra safety features, but not for those with limited space or minimalist preferences.
Pros:- Large 30L capacity for ample storage
- Waterproof PU leather material
- Anti-scalding bottom for safety
- Easy access with quick-release and buckle closures
Cons:- Not compatible with some models like Sportster 48 Iron 883
- Requires at least 3 inches clearance from tailpipe
- Bulkier design may interfere with maneuverability
Best for: Harley Softail riders who prioritize safety features and large capacity for daily commuting and short trips.
Not ideal for: Riders with tight-fit bikes or those seeking a minimalist aesthetic, as these bags are bulkier and require specific clearance.
Bottom line: This set is ideal for riders needing maximum capacity combined with enhanced safety features, despite size and compatibility considerations.
SLMOTO Saddlebags with Conversion Brackets for Harley Softail 1984-2017, Gloss Black
This set of SLMOTO saddlebags offers a practical solution for Harley Softail owners who want a sleek, no-fuss upgrade. Made from durable ABS, these bags provide a high-quality look comparable to more expensive leather options like the KEMIMOTO PU Leather Bags, but at a lower price point. The inclusion of mounting brackets, keys, and insert liners simplifies installation, making them ideal for riders who prefer a straightforward setup without hunting for accessories. While they fit a broad range of Softail models from 1984 to 2017, they exclude some popular variants like the Softail Slim and Deuce, which could be limiting for certain owners. Compared to the XMT-MOTO Hard Saddlebags, these are lighter and easier to install but lack detailed instructions and are less tailored for specific models, which could lead to confusion. The glossy black finish adds a sleek aesthetic, perfect for riders seeking a clean look without the expense of custom paint.
Pros:- Affordable price point for high-quality ABS construction
- Includes all necessary hardware and keys for convenience
- Sleek gloss black finish for a modern look
- Easy to install with provided brackets and liners
Cons:- Excludes certain popular Softail models like Slim and Deuce
- No detailed installation instructions included
- Limited compatibility with models featuring single-sided dual exhaust
Best for: Budget-conscious Softail owners wanting a durable, easy-to-install saddlebag without extensive customization.
Not ideal for: Owners of Softail Slim or Deuce models who need fitment specific to their bikes or prefer detailed instructions for installation.
- Fitment:Harley Softail 1984-2017 (excluding Softail Slim and Deuce)
- Color:Vivid Black
- Material:High-quality ABS
- Includes:Pair of saddlebags, mounting brackets, keys, insert liners
- Dimensions:As shown in the picture
- Installation:Includes hardware, no instructions
Bottom line: This set is a smart choice for budget-oriented riders who want a durable, straightforward saddlebag solution for most Softail models.
How We Picked
To select the best saddlebags for Harley Softail, I evaluated factors such as build quality, weatherproofing, ease of mounting, capacity, and overall value. I also considered user reviews and brand reputation to gauge long-term durability and satisfaction. Products were ranked based on how well they balance these elements, prioritizing secure fitment for Softail models, resistance to the elements, and practical features like lockable lids or added storage. The goal was to identify options that suit different rider needs—from casual riders to long-distance travelers—while maintaining high standards of quality and usability.Factors to Consider When Choosing Best Saddlebags For Harley Softail
Choosing the right saddlebags for your Harley Softail involves more than just picking a style. You need to consider how much storage you need, how weatherproof the bags are, and how easy they are to install and remove. Additionally, think about the overall durability and whether the bags complement your bike’s look. Making informed decisions on these factors helps ensure you get saddlebags that suit your riding habits and budget, avoiding common pitfalls like overloading or poor fitment.Capacity and Size
Assess your typical riding needs to determine the right capacity. If you plan long trips or carry a lot of gear, larger bags like the KEMIMOTO 30L options are beneficial. However, oversized saddlebags can impact handling and aesthetics, especially on smaller Softails. For daily commuting or shorter rides, compact options may suffice and maintain a cleaner profile. Striking a balance between capacity and maneuverability is key to avoiding cumbersome setups or frequent overpacking.
Weatherproofing and Material
Durability largely depends on the materials used. PU leather with waterproof linings is common and offers good protection against rain and splashes. For riders in wet climates, fully waterproof or water-resistant features are worth paying a premium for. Cheaper bags may look nice initially but often fail in harsh weather, leading to damaged contents. Think about your typical riding environment to select bags that will withstand the elements without additional covers or liners.
Mounting and Fitment
Secure mounting is essential to prevent bags from shifting or falling off. Look for saddlebags designed specifically for Softail models with compatible brackets or straps. Some bags offer quick-release systems for convenience, while others require more involved installation. Overly complex mounting systems can frustrate daily use, so evaluate how user-friendly the setup is—especially if you plan to remove and reattach the bags frequently.
Design and Aesthetics
Since saddlebags are a prominent visual feature, choose styles that complement your bike’s look. Classic leather and gloss black finishes tend to suit traditional Softails, but options like painted or stretched bags add a modern or custom touch. Consider whether you prefer a sleek, minimalist profile or larger, more visible storage. Remember, aesthetic choices can influence your overall riding experience and how well the bags integrate with your bike’s style.
Price and Value
Higher-priced saddlebags typically offer better materials, weatherproofing, and security features. However, budget options can serve well for casual riders or those just starting out. Evaluate whether the extra cost aligns with your needs—if you’re a long-distance rider, investing in durable, weatherproof bags makes sense. Conversely, if you only ride occasionally, a more affordable but less feature-rich option might be sufficient and save you money.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I install saddlebags on any Harley Softail model?
While many saddlebags are designed to fit most Softail models, compatibility depends on your specific year and configuration. Some bags come with adjustable mounting brackets that fit a range of models, but others are model-specific. It’s important to verify the mounting system and ensure it matches your bike’s frame and fender setup. Reading product specifications and consulting with the manufacturer can help avoid fitment issues and ensure a secure, stable installation.
Are waterproof saddlebags worth the extra cost?
Investing in waterproof saddlebags is generally worthwhile if you frequently ride in wet conditions or unpredictable weather. Waterproof bags protect your gear from rain, splashes, and road spray, extending their lifespan and keeping contents dry. Cheaper, non-waterproof options might save money upfront but often require additional covers or liners, adding inconvenience. For serious riders, the durability and peace of mind provided by waterproof features justify the higher price.
How much capacity do I really need for a weekend trip?
The amount of storage needed depends on your packing style and trip length. For a weekend trip, 20-30L of capacity typically suffices for clothing, essentials, and small gear. Larger bags like the KEMIMOTO 30L models give you flexibility and extra space if you pack heavily or bring along extra items. Overloading bags can affect handling and may strain mounting points, so choose a size that matches your packing habits to maintain safety and comfort.
Should I prioritize style or function when choosing saddlebags?
Both style and function matter, but your choice should align with your riding priorities. If you mainly commute or enjoy casual rides, a stylish, sleek design that complements your Softail’s look might be best. For touring or long-distance rides, durability, capacity, and weatherproofing should take precedence. Balancing aesthetics with practical features ensures you get saddlebags that look great and perform reliably over time.
What maintenance do saddlebags require to stay in good condition?
Routine maintenance involves cleaning the bags with mild soap and water to remove dirt and grime. If made of leather, occasional conditioning helps prevent cracking and keeps the material supple. For waterproof models, inspecting for tears and ensuring zippers or closures work smoothly is important. Proper storage when not in use, such as keeping bags in a dry, cool place, prolongs their lifespan and maintains their appearance and functionality.
Conclusion
For riders seeking the best overall balance of quality, security, and style, the Unknown Product offers a versatile, durable choice suitable for most Softail models. Budget-conscious buyers might prefer the XMT-MOTO Hard Saddlebags for their reliability and classic look, while long-distance travelers should consider the KEMIMOTO Large Capacity Bags for maximum storage. Beginners or casual riders will find affordable, easy-to-install options that still meet basic needs, whereas enthusiasts wanting a premium, custom aesthetic should look at higher-end, stylish options. Your ideal choice depends on how you ride and what you prioritize most in a saddlebag.
